Is Avril Lavigne really dead? The rollicking podcast taking on the internet’s wildest rumour

internet’s wildest rumour

This article is more than 2 months old

The ludicrous theory that the singer was replaced by a lookalike set the internet on fire. Now, an addictive new podcast aims to finally get to the bottom of it

n 2011, a Brazilian blog called Avril Está Morta (Avril is Dead) put forth a ludicrous theory. What if Avril Lavigne wasn’t Avril Lavigne? What if she had been replaced by a lookalike shortly after the release of her debut album, 2002’s Let Go, and this lookalike had pursued her career for nearly a decade?

The theory quickly caught fire online. The story goes that Lavigne was plunged into a deep depression after the death of her grandfather and, her stresses compounded by the pressures of fame, killed herself in 2002. But the cynical, money-grubbing record executives who controlled her career couldn’t let go of this cash cow, so they drafted in a lookalike named Melissa to play Lavigne.

It’s one of those theories that sounds preposterous but contains just enough details to keep people from dismissing it out of hand. Lavigne’s appearance has changed a little (although 22 years will do that to you), as has her music (possibly because she isn’t a teenage girl any more) and her handwriting. Plus, she once wrote “Melissa” on her hand in a photoshoot. Suspicious or what?

It’s the sort of rumour on which the internet thrives, one that appeals to the reptilian slice of your brain that gets itchy when you think about conspiracy theories. Want to read something into her lyrics? By all means. Want to scrutinise the moles on Lavigne’s body in detail? Go ahead, creep. The theory is a hall of mirrors in which you can easily get lost.

Now it is the subject of a BBC Sounds podcast, Who Replaced Avril Lavigne?. A lot of podcasts would approach this subject with journalistic rigour, seeking to present a definitive answer. But Who Replaced Avril Lavigne? isn’t interested in any of this.

Melissa, is that you? … Avril Lavigne on stage. Photograph: Jason Kempin/Getty Images

Its host, the Irish comedian Joanne McNally, doesn’t have the focus to put this rumour to bed. Yes, she conducts interviews. But on the basis of the first three episodes, none of them are relevant to the story. She interviews her best friend. She interviews Joe Lycett, who struggles to demonstrate even a basic understanding of who Lavigne is.

She interviews other podcasters, starting a terrible chain of events that will surely end with the podcast industry eating itself. She visits Lavigne’s home town but spends most of the trip looking at Lavigne’s childhood home, which doesn’t feel like a fruitful way to determine whether or not she died and was replaced by a doppelganger. If you came to Who Replaced Avril Lavigne? with a serious interest in the subject, there is a good chance you will abandon the series before the end of the first episode.

This would be a mistake, because it becomes clear that journalism isn’t the point of Who Replaced Avril Lavigne?. Lavigne’s supposed replacement acts as a vessel in which McNally can explore other subjects that interest her. She is extremely good at this. Her chat with Lycett ends up being about the weirdness of suddenly becoming very famous. He is remarkably wise, happily telling stories about how confused people are when they see him in supermarkets, even though they must know he needs to eat.

By the third episode, the series has found its feet. Lavigne is almost an afterthought as McNally embarks on a loose exploration of online conspiracy theories. She hints that she may be particularly susceptible to them, mentioning her brief interest in the 9/11 conspiracy film series Loose Change. Then she talks to Dave Benson Phillips, the beloved children’s television presenter, who in 2009 was the subject of a death hoax. Benson Phillips is funny (revealing that he heard about his death while clearing a dead seagull out of a gutter) and vulnerable (discussing how the hoax got so out of hand that he had to tell his loved ones he was still alive).

This podcast won’t give you any meaningful answers to the question in the title – but that isn’t the point. This is not a series about forensic scalpel cuts. This is a very funny woman riffing about how stupid the web is. Once your expectations have been sufficiently adjusted, it’s a hell of a show.

Related Posts

Breaking new: Michael Jackson’s only son, Paris Jackson, broke down in tears when he spoke out after 20 years of silence. And our suspicions were right, Diddy was… see more

Paris has experienced several difficulties since the death of her father. But, the gifted young lady is currently pursuing her own singing career. Despite the ups and downs in her…

Read more

Arsène Wenger’s smile during the Emirates construction days in 2004, just about 20 years old

Arsène Wenger’s smile during the Emirates construction days in 2004, just about 20 years old. Arsène Wenger’s smile during the Emirates construction days in 2004, just about 20 years old….

Read more

Arteta does not think Arsenal’s win against Leicester is a big deal

Mikel Arteta has downplayed the significance of Arsenal’s win against Leicester City in the broader context of the Premier League season. The Gunners are in the title race for the…

Read more

Arsenal now want to sign ‘jet-heeled’ winger wanted by Man Utd, 6 goals & 3 assists this season – report

Arsenal are interested in signing Hammarby winger Bazoumana Traore, according to Mirror. The Gunners were recently monitoring Traore in action for Hammarby during their top-flight match against Hacken. Mirror now reiterate the club’s interest in the 18-year-old,…

Read more

Arsenal: Declan Rice responds to ‘cheating’ claims as set-piece kings secure another win

The Gunners have picked up crucial points from set-pieces this season and last Mikel Arteta’s side were the best team at set-pieces in the Premier League last season and have…

Read more

Arsenal and Man City: Rivalry Heats Up On and Off the Pitch

Arsenal and Manchester City: A Rivalry Reignited The long-standing rivalry between Arsenal and Manchester City has reached new heights following their recent fiery encounter at the Etihad Stadium. What was already a competitive fixture has…

Read more

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

DMCA.com Protection Status